Commercial lawyers · Richmond, Melbourne

Granite staircase and fluted columns at the entrance of a classical public building

VCAT leasing disputes

Retail leasing disputes in Victoria often involve more than filing an application at VCAT. Depending on the dispute, the parties may first need to attend mediation through the Victorian Small Business Commission. Abbots Legal acts for landlords and tenants in VSBC mediation and VCAT retail leasing disputes throughout Melbourne and Victoria.

Not a retail lease? Litigation and dispute resolution

Consider this if…

  • You have a retail lease dispute and want to know where to start
  • The other side has applied to the VSBC or to VCAT
  • Mediation has failed and you have a VSBC certificate
  • You need to defend a VCAT claim or bring a counterclaim
  • You need urgent orders to stop a lockout

How it works

  1. Tell us about the dispute

    The lease, the notices and anything filed so far.

    Today

  2. We work out the right path

    VSBC first or straight to VCAT, and what to claim.

    Before anything is filed

  3. We prepare you for mediation

    Your position, your evidence and your settlement range.

    Quoted stage by stage

  4. We run the VCAT proceeding

    Points of claim or defence, evidence and the hearing.

    Quoted stage by stage

Fee

Quoted in writing before we start

Excludes: Disputes are quoted stage by stage rather than end to end, because neither we nor anyone else controls what the other side does.

We quote each stage in writing before you commit to it.

What VCAT deals with in leasing disputes

Understanding the correct process from the beginning can save time, cost and unnecessary procedural disputes.

VCAT deals with many disputes arising under the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic).

These can include disputes concerning:

  • rent arrears
  • outgoings
  • market rent reviews
  • repairs and maintenance
  • make-good
  • assignments
  • lease options and renewal
  • breach of lease
  • compensation
  • termination
  • possession
  • injunctions
  • relief against forfeiture

The appropriate forum depends on the nature of the lease and the dispute.

Not every commercial tenancy dispute belongs in VCAT, so jurisdiction should be considered before proceedings are commenced.

Victorian Small Business Commission leasing mediation

For many retail lease disputes, the first formal step is an application to the Victorian Small Business Commission (VSBC).

The VSBC provides preliminary dispute-resolution assistance and mediation for disputes between retail landlords and tenants.

Common matters referred to mediation include:

  • repairs and maintenance
  • outgoings
  • security deposits
  • rent disputes
  • make-good
  • lease obligations
  • termination and surrender issues

The objective is to determine whether the parties can reach a commercial resolution without proceeding to a contested VCAT hearing.

Retail leasing disputes are the largest part of the VSBC's work: in 2024-25, disputes under the Retail Leases Act made up more than half of the applications it received (855 of 1,611).

How the VSBC process works

Application

A party applies online and provides details of the dispute together with relevant documents.

This may include:

  • the lease
  • disclosure statements
  • correspondence
  • default notices
  • rent ledgers
  • invoices
  • valuation material
  • repair reports
  • photographs

The material provided to the VSBC will generally be shared with the other party as part of the dispute-resolution process.

Preliminary resolution

A dispute resolution officer may contact the parties before mediation to clarify the issues and explore whether the matter can be resolved.

Some disputes are resolved at this stage without a formal mediation.

Mediation

If the matter proceeds, an independent mediator assists the parties in attempting to negotiate an agreement.

The mediator does not decide who is right or impose an outcome.

For mediation to be effective, each party should attend with a person who has authority to settle the dispute. The VSBC expressly requires participating parties to identify someone with full settlement authority.

Settlement

Where agreement is reached, the terms are usually recorded in a written settlement document.

This may deal with rent, repairs, make-good, lease variations, surrender, security or other disputed obligations.

VSBC certificate

Where the dispute cannot be resolved, a VSBC certificate may allow the parties to proceed to VCAT where one is required.

Do you need VSBC mediation before VCAT?

For many retail tenancy disputes, the answer is yes.

However, there are important exceptions.

The VSBC currently identifies matters that may proceed directly to VCAT, including:

  • claims solely for unpaid rent
  • applications for relief against forfeiture
  • injunction applications
  • claims concerning key money

For other retail lease disputes, a VSBC certificate will commonly be required before VCAT proceedings can commence.

This distinction is particularly important where possession or an urgent lockout is involved.

Preparing for VSBC mediation

Successful mediation usually requires more than attending and explaining the dispute.

Before the session, parties should understand:

  • the legal position under the lease
  • their strongest and weakest arguments
  • the evidence supporting their claim
  • the financial value of the dispute
  • the outcome they actually want
  • the terms on which they are prepared to settle

For landlords, this may involve considering arrears, possession, security and future tenancy arrangements.

For tenants, it may involve maintaining occupation, reducing a disputed liability or negotiating an orderly exit.

We assist clients with preparing for mediation and negotiating settlement terms.

Starting a VCAT leasing proceeding

Where proceedings are necessary, the application should clearly identify the legal basis of the claim and the orders sought.

Depending on the matter, this can involve:

  • preparing the VCAT application
  • identifying the relevant statutory provisions
  • filing the required VSBC certificate
  • preparing points of claim
  • particularising losses or amounts sought
  • filing supporting documents
  • seeking interim orders

Poorly defined claims can create unnecessary procedural difficulties later in the proceeding.

We assist with framing the claim properly from the outset.

Responding to a VCAT application

A landlord or tenant receiving an application should review it promptly.

Depending on the claim, the response may involve:

  • preparing points of defence
  • disputing the factual allegations
  • challenging the amounts claimed
  • raising statutory defences
  • filing a counterclaim
  • preparing witness evidence
  • seeking further particulars
  • negotiating settlement

VCAT may issue procedural orders requiring documents to be filed within particular timeframes.

We assist clients with complying with those requirements and preparing the matter for hearing.

Directions hearings and procedural orders

Before the final hearing, VCAT may conduct a directions hearing or issue directions about how the matter is to proceed.

These may concern:

  • pleadings
  • discovery or document exchange
  • witness statements
  • expert reports
  • valuation evidence
  • hearing preparation
  • mediation or compulsory conference

The purpose is to identify the issues and ensure the matter is ready for determination.

Evidence in a VCAT lease dispute

The evidence required will depend on the particular dispute.

It may include:

  • Lease documentation. Executed leases, variations, assignments and disclosure statements.
  • Financial records. Rent ledgers, bank records, invoices and statements.
  • Notices. Default notices, rent review notices and other formal correspondence.
  • Condition evidence. Photographs, entry reports and inspection records.
  • Expert evidence. Valuation, building, repair or accounting evidence.
  • Witness evidence. Statements concerning negotiations, breaches or events affecting the tenancy.

A strong legal argument still needs evidence capable of supporting it.

VCAT mediation and compulsory conferences

A proceeding may still settle after it reaches VCAT.

VCAT can refer parties to mediation or a compulsory conference before the final hearing.

Possible settlement arrangements include:

  • payment of arrears
  • instalment arrangements
  • reduction or withdrawal of disputed claims
  • performance of repair works
  • agreement about make-good
  • variation of the lease
  • agreed surrender
  • release of a bank guarantee or security deposit
  • mutual releases

Where settlement is reached, the terms should clearly deal with the entire dispute and any ongoing tenancy arrangements.

VCAT retail lease hearings

If the dispute does not resolve, the matter may proceed to a contested hearing.

The Tribunal will consider the evidence, the lease, the Retail Leases Act and the parties' legal submissions.

Depending on the nature of the case, witnesses and experts may be required to give evidence.

There is no automatic right to legal representation at VCAT. Under section 62 of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 (Vic), a party may be represented by a lawyer if all parties agree, if another party has a lawyer, or with the Tribunal's permission.

We assist with preparing cases for hearing and seek permission to appear where required.

Orders available in VCAT leasing matters

Depending on its jurisdiction and the claim, VCAT may make orders concerning:

  • payment of money
  • rent arrears
  • compensation
  • lease obligations
  • injunctions
  • rectification
  • possession
  • forfeiture
  • relief against forfeiture
  • other statutory relief

The appropriate orders should be identified carefully when the application is commenced.

Urgent VCAT injunctions

Some leasing disputes require immediate intervention.

For example, a tenant may need to prevent an imminent lockout or preserve access to premises while the underlying dispute is determined.

An application for an injunction can generally proceed without first obtaining the VSBC certificate that applies to many other retail tenancy disputes.

Urgent applications require focused evidence explaining:

  • what is about to happen
  • why the position cannot wait
  • the legal basis for the orders sought
  • the harm likely to occur without relief

Our lockouts and re-entry page deals with these applications in greater detail.

Costs in VCAT retail leasing matters

Costs should be considered before commencing proceedings.

In retail tenancy disputes, each party generally bears its own costs, even if it succeeds (section 92 of the Retail Leases Act).

The parties' conduct can change that: VCAT may order costs where a party conducted the proceeding in a vexatious way that unnecessarily disadvantaged the other party, or refused to take part in or withdrew from mediation.

We advise on potential costs exposure as part of the litigation strategy.

VCAT leasing dispute lawyers in Melbourne

Abbots Legal advises and represents commercial landlords and tenants throughout Melbourne and Victoria in retail lease disputes.

We assist with VSBC mediation, VCAT applications, points of claim and defence, evidence, compulsory conferences, injunctions, settlement negotiations and hearings.

Whether you are commencing a claim or responding to proceedings, we can help you navigate the process and protect your commercial position.

Frequently asked questions

What happens if VSBC mediation fails?

Where required, a party may request a certificate allowing the dispute to proceed to VCAT.

Can a landlord commence VCAT proceedings?

Yes, where VCAT has jurisdiction over the particular retail tenancy dispute.

Can a tenant defend a VCAT claim?

Yes. A tenant can respond to the allegations, file defence material and bring an appropriate counterclaim where available.

Can VCAT order compensation?

Yes, where it has jurisdiction and the legal requirements for the claim are established.

Can I settle at VCAT?

Yes. Matters frequently settle through negotiation, mediation or compulsory conference before a final hearing.

Can a lawyer represent me at VCAT?

Yes, if all parties agree, if another party has a lawyer, or if the Tribunal gives permission.

Related services

What our clients say

5.0 from 22 Google reviews

  • We've used Abbots Legal for a number of retail leasing matters including drafting leases, subleases, assignments, default notices, and urgent injunctions. Nicholas is very knowledgeable, practical and always gives straight advice. They understand the Retail Leases Act and are great to deal with. Would definitely recommend Abbots Legal for retail leasing and landlord matters.

    MeganRetail Leasing

  • I work as an accountant and I have engaged Abbots Legal for a range of business matters, including intellectual property. Professional, responsive and commercially minded every time.

    Joshua O.Commercial Law

  • Our experience with Abbots Legal has been nothing but positive. In particular, Nicholas Kotsimbos went above and beyond for our particular circumstance. Good old fashioned five star customer service!

    Marc C.

  • Highly recommend Abbots Legal. They assisted me with my Will, Power of Attorney, and Medical Decision Maker documents and made the whole process simple and stress free. Professional, efficient, and easy to deal with.

    Nahid K.Wills & Estates

  • Great experience with Abbots Legal. They assisted with a commercial lease matter and made the process smooth and straightforward. Professional, responsive, and easy to deal with. Highly recommend!!

    Sara M.Retail Leasing

  • Abbots Legal provided invaluable support when I purchased my first business. Their guidance was clear, practical, professional and most importantly stress free. Highly recommend

    Ellie T.Commercial Law

  • Excellent advice on establishing our bloodline trust. The team (in particular Nicholas) explained everything clearly and provided very practical guidance for our estate planning.

    Jack V.Wills & Estates

  • Excellent advice on business structuring. The team was knowledgeable, practical, and made the process straightforward from start to finish.

    Aaron H.Business Structuring

  • Nick from Abbots Legal handled our commercial leasing matter quickly and explained everything thoroughly. Bonus that they're around the corner in Richmond.

    Stephanie J.Retail Leasing

  • Had a great experience with Nicholas. His commercial law advice was clear and exactly what I needed.

    Tijen A.Commercial Law

  • Amazing dealing with the team at Abbots Legal. Our estate planning couldn't have been simpler

    Georgette K.Wills & Estates

  • Incredible work by Nick and the team. Had some problems with a tenant and Nick and gotten some great settlement terms. Would highly recommend if you want lawyers that are straight to the point and dont mess about.

    Wiz Z.Litigation & Dispute Resolution

  • Abbots Legal were exceptional when assisting me in the start up of my business. Highly recommend these folk. Good, honest people.

    Jesse F.Business Structuring

  • Nicholas and the team have been there to assist me and my business since day one. Extremely diligent and responsive - would highly recommend

    Jeffrey H.Commercial Law

  • Work in tandem with the team at Abbots Legal daily. Can't fault them and their team. Recommend without hesitation - Ask for Nick

    Gregory S.

  • Nick was very helpful with all proceedings, can't recommend enough 👍

    Jonathan H.