Commercial lawyers · Richmond, Melbourne

Three people going through printed documents on a light timber meeting table, one turning a page

Commercial and retail lease disputes

Commercial and retail lease disputes can quickly affect cash flow, business operations and the relationship between landlord and tenant. A disagreement about rent, outgoings or repairs can turn into a dispute about breach, termination or the right to remain in the premises. Abbots Legal advises and represents landlords and tenants throughout Melbourne and Victoria.

Arrears still owed after the lease ended? Commercial debt recovery

Consider this if…

  • You are in dispute over rent, arrears or outgoings
  • Your landlord says you are in breach and you disagree
  • An option to renew was exercised late, or the landlord says it was
  • Repairs or essential services are not being attended to
  • There is a disagreement about make good or the bank guarantee
  • You have been served with, or need to serve, a notice

How it works

  1. Send us the lease and any notices

    And tell us any deadline you are working to.

    Today

  2. We assess the merits

    What the lease and the law say, and what the dispute is worth.

    Quoted before we start

  3. We negotiate

    A properly argued letter, then settlement discussions.

    Quoted stage by stage

  4. Mediation, then VCAT or court

    Only if the dispute does not resolve sooner.

    Quoted stage by stage

Fee

Quoted in writing before we start

Excludes: Disputes are quoted stage by stage rather than end to end, because neither we nor anyone else controls what the other side does.

We quote each stage in writing before you commit to it.

Where lease disputes start

A lease dispute can start at any point in a tenancy.

Some concern the interpretation of a particular clause. Others involve substantial arrears, alleged breaches of lease or competing claims about whether the tenancy should continue.

We advise landlords and tenants on:

  • their rights under the lease
  • whether the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) applies
  • the validity of notices that have been issued
  • available contractual and statutory remedies
  • whether the dispute should be negotiated, mediated or litigated
  • the appropriate forum for formal proceedings

Early advice can be particularly important where a default notice has been served or termination is being threatened.

Our focus is on resolving the immediate problem while protecting your broader commercial position.

Retail lease disputes in Victoria

Retail premises leases can involve additional rights and obligations under the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic).

The Act regulates important aspects of qualifying retail leases, including disclosure, outgoings, rent reviews, assignments and dispute resolution.

Some statutory protections operate despite inconsistent provisions in the lease.

It is therefore important to consider both the wording of the lease and the legislation before determining whether a landlord or tenant is entitled to take a particular step.

We advise on disputes involving retail shops, hospitality premises, professional services, gyms and other businesses operating from premises covered by the Act.

Rent arrears and unpaid rent

Rent arrears are one of the most common commercial leasing disputes.

For landlords, continuing arrears can affect cash flow and may justify formal enforcement action.

For tenants, an unresolved rental default can result in interest, legal costs, default notices and potential termination.

We assist with:

  • outstanding rent and arrears claims
  • rent ledgers and disputed amounts
  • payment plans
  • interest on overdue rent
  • recovery against guarantors
  • default notices
  • termination and possession issues

Where a landlord is considering re-entry, the legal position should be reviewed before possession is taken.

Outgoings disputes

Commercial leases commonly require tenants to contribute towards some or all property outgoings.

Disputes may concern:

  • council and water charges
  • insurance
  • owners corporation expenses
  • management costs
  • repairs and maintenance
  • land tax
  • estimates and annual reconciliations

For retail leases, the Retail Leases Act imposes additional requirements concerning the recovery and disclosure of outgoings.

We advise landlords and tenants on whether particular amounts are recoverable and assist with disputed outgoings claims.

Rent review and market rent disputes

Rent reviews can become contentious where the parties disagree about the operation of a CPI, fixed or market rent review clause.

Market reviews can involve additional issues concerning valuation methodology, comparable premises and statutory requirements.

We advise on:

  • market rent reviews
  • rent review notices
  • disputed rent increases
  • retail lease rent review requirements
  • valuation disputes
  • the operation of rent review clauses

Repairs and maintenance disputes

Landlords and tenants often disagree about responsibility for maintaining or repairing the premises.

The legal position may depend on the wording of the lease, the nature of the defect and whether the Retail Leases Act applies.

Common disputes include:

  • structural repairs
  • air-conditioning and essential services
  • plumbing and electrical issues
  • damage caused by a tenant
  • replacement of fixtures or equipment
  • compliance and safety works

We review the lease and applicable legislation to determine where responsibility lies and what remedies may be available.

Make-good and end-of-lease claims

At the end of a lease, disagreements frequently arise about the condition in which the premises must be returned.

Make-good disputes may involve:

  • claims against a bank guarantee or security deposit
  • removal of fit-out and signage
  • reinstatement of alterations
  • repairs, repainting and cleaning
  • restoring floors or ceilings

The starting point is the actual make-good clause and the condition of the premises when possession was originally given.

We advise on make-good claims, dilapidation reports, repair quotations and negotiated end-of-lease settlements.

Lease assignment disputes

A dispute may arise where a tenant wishes to sell its business and assign the lease to a purchaser.

Issues can include:

  • whether landlord consent can be withheld
  • the financial standing of the proposed assignee
  • information required by the landlord
  • disclosure obligations
  • security requirements
  • guarantees
  • assignment costs
  • release of the outgoing tenant and guarantors

For qualifying retail leases, the Retail Leases Act contains specific provisions governing assignments and landlord consent.

Renewal options and lease expiry disputes

Options to renew are often highly valuable, particularly where a business has established goodwill at a particular location.

Disputes may arise over whether:

  • the option was exercised on time
  • the notice complied with the lease
  • existing defaults affect the tenant's rights
  • the landlord was required to give certain notices
  • the renewed rent has been properly determined
  • the tenant is entitled to remain in occupation

We advise on contested options, lease renewals and holding-over arrangements.

Breach of lease and default notices

A landlord may allege that a tenant has breached the lease by failing to pay rent, carrying out unauthorised works, using the premises improperly or failing to comply with another obligation.

A tenant receiving a default notice should not assume that termination is inevitable.

Questions can arise about whether:

  • there has actually been a breach
  • the notice correctly identifies the breach
  • the breach can be remedied
  • sufficient time has been provided
  • the landlord has waived the breach
  • the proposed termination is legally available

We advise landlords on enforcing lease obligations and tenants on responding to default notices and threatened termination.

Permitted use and unauthorised occupation

A lease commonly limits the purpose for which premises may be used.

Disputes can arise where the tenant:

  • changes its business operations
  • allows another business to occupy part of the premises
  • licenses or subleases space
  • operates outside the permitted use
  • requires additional planning or regulatory approvals

We advise on permitted-use clauses, licences, subleases and unauthorised occupation.

Lease termination and surrender disputes

Sometimes the commercial relationship has reached a point where neither party wants the tenancy to continue.

Rather than litigating every issue, the parties may negotiate an agreed surrender.

A settlement might address:

  • the surrender date
  • rent arrears
  • future rent
  • make-good
  • security deposits and bank guarantees
  • removal of goods
  • mutual releases
  • confidentiality

We prepare deeds of surrender and settlement arrangements designed to bring the tenancy to an orderly end.

Advice for commercial landlords

We regularly assist landlords with:

  • rent recovery
  • default notices
  • outgoings disputes
  • tenant breaches
  • bank guarantees
  • make-good claims
  • assignment disputes
  • guarantor claims
  • lease termination
  • re-entry and possession

Where termination or a lockout is contemplated, legal advice should be obtained before action is taken.

Advice for commercial tenants

We assist tenants with:

  • responding to default notices
  • rent and outgoings disputes
  • repair and maintenance claims
  • option and renewal disputes
  • make-good claims
  • assignment difficulties
  • lease termination
  • threatened lockouts
  • compensation claims
  • negotiated lease exits

Where continued occupation is at risk, urgent advice may be required.

Resolving a lease dispute

Litigation is not always the most commercial outcome.

Depending on the issue, a dispute may be resolved through:

  • direct negotiation
  • a payment arrangement
  • variation of the lease
  • Victorian Small Business Commission mediation
  • an agreed surrender
  • formal settlement terms
  • VCAT proceedings
  • court proceedings

We consider both the legal merits and the practical commercial objective.

Where formal proceedings are necessary, we assist with the appropriate process, including VSBC mediation and VCAT proceedings.

Commercial and retail lease dispute lawyers in Melbourne

Abbots Legal is a Richmond-based commercial leasing law firm advising landlords and tenants throughout Melbourne and Victoria.

We assist with rent arrears, outgoings, repairs, make-good, assignments, options, defaults, termination and possession disputes.

Whether you are enforcing a lease or responding to a claim made against you, we can help you understand your legal position and determine the most commercially appropriate next step.

Frequently asked questions

Can a landlord terminate a lease for unpaid rent?

Potentially. The available rights depend on the lease, the arrears and applicable law. Termination and re-entry should be carefully assessed before action is taken.

Can a tenant dispute commercial lease outgoings?

Yes. The recoverability of outgoings depends on the lease and applicable legislation. Retail leases are subject to additional statutory requirements.

Can a tenant challenge a make-good claim?

Yes. The claim should be tested against what the lease actually requires, the present state of the premises and the works being demanded.

Does every leasing dispute go to VCAT?

No. The appropriate forum depends on the type of lease, the nature of the dispute and the legislation governing it.

Can a lease dispute be settled without a hearing?

Yes. Many commercial and retail leasing disputes are resolved through negotiation, VSBC mediation or negotiated settlement terms.

Related services

What our clients say

5.0 from 22 Google reviews

  • We've used Abbots Legal for a number of retail leasing matters including drafting leases, subleases, assignments, default notices, and urgent injunctions. Nicholas is very knowledgeable, practical and always gives straight advice. They understand the Retail Leases Act and are great to deal with. Would definitely recommend Abbots Legal for retail leasing and landlord matters.

    MeganRetail Leasing

  • I work as an accountant and I have engaged Abbots Legal for a range of business matters, including intellectual property. Professional, responsive and commercially minded every time.

    Joshua O.Commercial Law

  • Our experience with Abbots Legal has been nothing but positive. In particular, Nicholas Kotsimbos went above and beyond for our particular circumstance. Good old fashioned five star customer service!

    Marc C.

  • Highly recommend Abbots Legal. They assisted me with my Will, Power of Attorney, and Medical Decision Maker documents and made the whole process simple and stress free. Professional, efficient, and easy to deal with.

    Nahid K.Wills & Estates

  • Great experience with Abbots Legal. They assisted with a commercial lease matter and made the process smooth and straightforward. Professional, responsive, and easy to deal with. Highly recommend!!

    Sara M.Retail Leasing

  • Abbots Legal provided invaluable support when I purchased my first business. Their guidance was clear, practical, professional and most importantly stress free. Highly recommend

    Ellie T.Commercial Law

  • Excellent advice on establishing our bloodline trust. The team (in particular Nicholas) explained everything clearly and provided very practical guidance for our estate planning.

    Jack V.Wills & Estates

  • Excellent advice on business structuring. The team was knowledgeable, practical, and made the process straightforward from start to finish.

    Aaron H.Business Structuring

  • Nick from Abbots Legal handled our commercial leasing matter quickly and explained everything thoroughly. Bonus that they're around the corner in Richmond.

    Stephanie J.Retail Leasing

  • Had a great experience with Nicholas. His commercial law advice was clear and exactly what I needed.

    Tijen A.Commercial Law

  • Amazing dealing with the team at Abbots Legal. Our estate planning couldn't have been simpler

    Georgette K.Wills & Estates

  • Incredible work by Nick and the team. Had some problems with a tenant and Nick and gotten some great settlement terms. Would highly recommend if you want lawyers that are straight to the point and dont mess about.

    Wiz Z.Litigation & Dispute Resolution

  • Abbots Legal were exceptional when assisting me in the start up of my business. Highly recommend these folk. Good, honest people.

    Jesse F.Business Structuring

  • Nicholas and the team have been there to assist me and my business since day one. Extremely diligent and responsive - would highly recommend

    Jeffrey H.Commercial Law

  • Work in tandem with the team at Abbots Legal daily. Can't fault them and their team. Recommend without hesitation - Ask for Nick

    Gregory S.

  • Nick was very helpful with all proceedings, can't recommend enough 👍

    Jonathan H.