Consider this if…
- Your lease is ending and you need to know what must be removed or reinstated
- The landlord has sent a make-good scope or claim
- You want to know what your make-good exposure is before you sign
- Your bank guarantee or security deposit is being held over make-good
- You are selling the business and the buyer needs to know the make-good position
- You are a landlord and the premises have been handed back in poor condition
How it works
Send us the lease and the claim
The lease and any variations, what you have from the start of the lease, and whatever the landlord has sent.
Today
We work out what the obligation actually is
Item by item, against the lease wording and the condition at the start.
With the review
You get a position in writing
What we consider is owed, what is arguable, and what we would propose.
With the review
We negotiate or run the dispute
With the landlord or tenant, stage by stage.
Quoted before we start
Fee
Quoted in writing before we start
We quote a fixed fee in writing before any work begins.
What does make-good mean in a commercial lease?
Make-good refers to the tenant's obligation to return the premises in the condition required by the lease.
The clause may require the tenant to remove signage, partitions, flooring, counters, equipment or other fit-out. It may also require repairs or reinstatement of alterations made during the tenancy.
The extent of the obligation depends on the wording of the lease and any relevant agreement between the parties.
What condition must the premises be returned in?
The lease is the starting point, but the condition of the premises when the tenant first took occupation can also be important.
Condition reports, photographs, fit-out plans and correspondence may help establish what was already present and what was installed or changed by the tenant.
Tenants should not assume that fair wear and tear removes every make-good obligation. The actual lease wording needs to be considered.
Make-good and fit-out
Fit-out is often the main source of disagreement.
A tenant may have installed partitions, flooring, signage, lighting, plumbing, electrical works or other fixtures. The lease may require some or all of these items to be removed, even where they were installed with the landlord's approval.
If the landlord is willing to allow some items to remain, that arrangement should be documented clearly before the lease ends.
Air-conditioning and other equipment
Air-conditioning can create particular issues at the end of a lease.
The parties may need to establish who owns the equipment, who installed it, whether it forms part of the landlord's plant and equipment, and whether the tenant is required to remove or reinstate it.
The position can differ depending on the lease and the equipment involved. A general make-good clause should not be considered in isolation from any other provisions dealing with landlord's fixtures, repairs and maintenance.
When should you deal with make-good?
It is usually better to start planning several months before the lease expires.
An early inspection can identify the work likely to be required and provide time for the parties to agree on the scope. It also gives the tenant an opportunity to obtain quotations and organise contractors before the final days of occupation.
Waiting until the premises have been vacated can make disagreements more difficult to resolve.
Can a landlord claim make-good costs?
A landlord may have rights to recover costs where the tenant has failed to comply with its contractual obligations. The amount recoverable depends on the lease, the work required and the circumstances.
Landlords should document the condition of the premises and the works required. Tenants should consider obtaining advice before accepting a substantial make-good claim or agreeing to undertake work that may not be required by the lease.
Make-good and security deposits
Outstanding make-good obligations can affect discussions about releasing a bank guarantee or security deposit.
The parties should identify any outstanding work, agree on what needs to be done where possible and address the security arrangements promptly.
Make-good when selling a business
A business sale does not automatically remove the seller's lease obligations.
The lease should be reviewed as part of the transaction so that the purchaser and vendor understand the position on make-good, existing breaches and any assignment of the lease.
Make-good lawyers in Melbourne
Abbots Legal advises landlords and tenants on commercial and retail lease make-good obligations, fit-out removal, reinstatement and make-good disputes across Melbourne and Victoria.
Contact us to review your lease before the end of the term or to discuss a make-good claim.
Frequently asked questions
What is a make-good clause?
It sets out the tenant's obligations to return the premises in the required condition when the lease ends.
Does make-good include removing fit-out?
It can. The answer depends on the lease and any agreement about the fit-out.
Can make-good obligations be negotiated?
Yes. They can be negotiated before a lease is signed and, in some circumstances, when the lease is approaching expiry.
When should I arrange a make-good inspection?
Ideally, several months before the lease ends so that the parties have time to assess the work and resolve disagreements.


