Commercial lawyers · Richmond, Melbourne

Smartphone calculator, open notebook and printed charts on a white desk

Rent reviews and market rent reviews

A rent review can significantly increase, or in a market rent review potentially reduce, the rent payable during a lease or on renewal. We advise landlords and tenants on market, CPI and fixed reviews, renewals and rent review disputes. Received a rent review notice or market rent proposal? Send us the lease and the notice.

Consider this if…

  • You have received a rent review notice or a proposed market rent
  • Your landlord has sent a section 28 notice before an option deadline
  • Your retail lease is entering an option period with a market review
  • You think a rent review clause may not comply with the Retail Leases Act
  • You and the other side cannot agree on market rent

How it works

  1. Send us the lease and the notice

    The lease, the rent review notice or market rent proposal, and any section 28 notice, with the dates in them.

    As soon as the notice arrives

  2. We review the clause and the proposal

    We check the review date, the review mechanism, the notice requirements and whether the Retail Leases Act applies.

    Before you respond

  3. We advise on your position

    What rent is properly payable, the risks, and the options open to you, in plain English.

    Before any option or response deadline

  4. Negotiate or resolve

    Where appropriate, we negotiate the rent, deal with a specialist retail valuer, or act in Victorian Small Business Commission or VCAT processes.

    If agreement is not reached

Fee

Quoted in writing before we start

Turnaround

Tell us the review or option deadline in your notice when you contact us.

Rent reviews in a commercial or retail lease

A rent review is a mechanism in a lease that allows the rent to change at an agreed time during the lease term or when a lease is renewed. Rent reviews are one of the most important financial provisions in a commercial or retail lease.

Common rent review mechanisms include:

  • fixed percentage increases
  • CPI or other index-based reviews
  • fixed dollar increases
  • market rent reviews

The correct treatment depends on the wording of the lease and, for retail premises in Victoria, the requirements of the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic).

A rent review clause should not be considered in isolation. The review date, notice provisions, lease term, option provisions and any applicable statutory requirements can all affect the amount of rent ultimately payable.

Market rent reviews

A market rent review is different from a fixed or CPI increase. Instead of applying a predetermined percentage or index, it seeks to establish the current market rent for the premises at the review date.

Market rent reviews are commonly relevant when:

  • a retail lease enters an option period
  • a lease provides for market rent at renewal
  • a lease contains a market review during the term
  • the landlord proposes a new market rent
  • the tenant disputes the proposed rent

If the parties cannot agree on market rent under a Victorian retail lease, the matter may be referred to a specialist retail valuer in accordance with the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic).

What is considered in a market rent review?

A market rent review is concerned with the rent the premises could reasonably command in the current market. Relevant matters can include:

  • the location of the premises
  • size and configuration
  • permitted use
  • condition of the premises
  • the terms of the lease
  • comparable rental evidence
  • incentives offered in comparable transactions
  • outgoings and the tenant's obligations
  • other relevant market conditions

For a retail premises lease, section 37 of the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) sets out the matters to be taken into account when determining current market rent. The value of the tenant's goodwill and the tenant's fixtures and fittings are not to be taken into account.

Fixed, CPI or market rent: what's the difference?

Understanding the rent review mechanism is critical before entering into or renewing a lease.

Fixed percentage review

A fixed percentage review increases the rent by an agreed percentage at a particular time. For example:

Rent increases by 4% on each anniversary of the lease.

The advantage is certainty: both parties know in advance what the rent will be.

CPI review

A CPI review adjusts the rent by reference to an independently published index. It is linked to changes in prices and inflation rather than the actual rental market for the premises.

Market rent review

A market rent review sets the rent by reference to the current market rental value of the premises. Unlike a fixed or CPI review, the outcome is not necessarily an increase. If market evidence supports a lower rent, a market rent review can result in the rent being reduced.

Retail lease rent reviews in Victoria

For retail premises in Victoria, rent reviews are subject to the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic). Section 35 regulates rent review provisions in retail leases and requires the lease to specify when the rent is to be reviewed and the basis or formula for determining the new rent.

Permitted mechanisms can include:

  • a fixed percentage
  • an independently published index
  • a fixed amount
  • current market rent
  • another permitted basis or formula

The drafting of the rent review clause is therefore extremely important. A clause that appears commercially straightforward may not operate as intended if it does not comply with the Act.

Prohibited rent review clauses

One of the most important issues we consider when reviewing a retail lease is whether the rent review clause complies with section 35 of the Retail Leases Act.

For example, a clause should not simply combine multiple review mechanisms at the same review date in a way that is inconsistent with the Act. A clause providing for:

CPI plus a further fixed percentage increase

may raise compliance issues. Similarly, provisions that effectively require the rent to increase by whichever of two different review mechanisms produces the higher rent need to be carefully examined.

Rent ratchets

A rent ratchet is a provision intended to prevent rent from decreasing following a market rent review. For example, a clause might attempt to provide that:

The reviewed rent cannot be lower than the rent immediately before the review.

For retail premises, section 35 prohibits provisions that prevent or limit a reduction in rent following a review.

The position on caps on rent increases is more nuanced. Recent Victorian authority has confirmed that a cap on the outcome of a valid rent review is not necessarily prohibited simply because it limits the amount by which rent can increase. The drafting and operation of the particular clause must be considered.

If you are a landlord or tenant dealing with a potentially invalid rent review clause, we recommend having the lease reviewed before the rent is adjusted.

Section 28 notices and rent on renewal

Section 28 of the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) is particularly important where a retail lease contains an option to renew.

A landlord must generally give the tenant the required notice at least three months before the last date on which the option can be exercised. The notice must include important information about the renewal, including the rent payable for the first 12 months of the renewed term and information about the tenant's rights to an early rent review.

This means section 28 notices, lease options and market rent reviews can be closely connected. A tenant who receives a section 28 notice should not simply exercise the option without considering the proposed rent.

Early market rent reviews

Where the retail lease provides for a market rent review on renewal, a tenant may have a right to request an early rent review after receiving the section 28 notice.

The timing is important. A tenant generally needs to request the early rent review within the statutory period, and the valuation process can affect the timing of the option exercise. For this reason, we recommend getting legal advice as soon as a section 28 notice is received.

If you cannot agree on market rent

If the parties cannot agree on the current market rent for a Victorian retail lease, the rent may be determined by a specialist retail valuer, who must determine it in accordance with the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic). If the parties cannot agree on the appointment of a specialist retail valuer, the Victorian Small Business Commission may become involved.

We can advise you before and during the valuation process and assist with the legal and commercial aspects of the dispute.

Rent review disputes

Rent review disputes can arise for a number of reasons. We assist landlords and tenants with disputes about:

  • the correct rent review date
  • whether the landlord has given the required notice
  • whether the rent review clause is valid
  • whether the correct review mechanism has been applied
  • CPI calculations
  • fixed percentage increases
  • market rent assessments
  • comparable rental evidence
  • rent ratchets
  • rent review caps
  • section 28 notices
  • early market rent reviews
  • specialist retail valuations
  • rent payable following renewal

Where necessary, we can assist with negotiations, Victorian Small Business Commission processes, VCAT proceedings and other dispute resolution processes.

Rent review advice for landlords

For landlords, a rent review should be approached carefully. We can assist with:

  • reviewing the rent review clause
  • calculating the proposed rent
  • preparing rent review notices
  • reviewing market rental evidence
  • advising on section 28 notices
  • lease renewals
  • negotiating market rent
  • dealing with specialist retail valuers
  • responding to tenant objections or disputes

The objective is to make sure the landlord receives the rent to which it is contractually and legally entitled, while complying with the applicable legislation.

Rent review advice for tenants

For tenants, a rent review can have a significant impact on the ongoing cost of running a business. We can review:

  • the lease
  • the rent review clause
  • the proposed increase
  • the landlord's calculations
  • market rental evidence
  • the section 28 notice
  • the proposed renewal rent
  • whether the review complies with the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic)

Where appropriate, we can negotiate with the landlord or assist with the valuation and dispute process.

Commercial lease rent reviews

Not every commercial lease is governed by the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic). For commercial premises outside the Act, the lease itself is particularly important. The parties may have agreed to rent reviews based on:

  • CPI
  • fixed percentages
  • fixed dollar increases
  • market rent
  • a combination of mechanisms at different review dates
  • another contractual mechanism

The validity and operation of the clause will depend on the lease and the applicable law. Our commercial leasing lawyers can review the clause and advise you on what rent is properly payable.

How we can help

We provide commercial leasing and rent review advice in Melbourne and throughout Victoria: rent review clauses; market, CPI and fixed rent reviews; retail and commercial lease rent reviews; section 28 notices and early market rent reviews; lease renewal and option advice; specialist retail valuations; rent review negotiations and disputes, including VCAT and Victorian Small Business Commission matters; and drafting and negotiating rent review provisions.

Why choose Abbots Legal for a rent review

Melbourne commercial leasing lawyers. Abbots Legal is a Melbourne law firm based in Richmond, with a particular focus on commercial property and leasing.

Leasing-focused advice. Rent reviews are not treated as an isolated calculation. We consider the rent review clause together with the wider lease, options, renewal provisions and applicable legislation.

Retail Leases Act experience. Where the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) applies, we consider the statutory requirements affecting the rent review and renewal process.

Practical commercial advice. We explain what the proposed rent means commercially and what options are available to you.

Landlord and tenant experience. We act for both landlords and tenants, giving us a practical understanding of the commercial issues on both sides of a rent review.

Frequently asked questions

What does a rent review lawyer do?

A rent review lawyer reviews the lease and the proposed rent adjustment, advises on the applicable review mechanism, and assists with notices, negotiations, market rent assessments and disputes.

What is a market rent review?

A market rent review determines the current rental value of premises by reference to the market and the requirements of the lease and, where applicable, the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic).

Can a market rent review reduce rent?

Yes. A market rent review is not necessarily an increase. If the evidence establishes that the current market rent is lower, the reviewed rent may be lower.

Can a retail lease use CPI plus a fixed percentage?

The precise drafting needs to be considered. Section 35 regulates the permitted basis for rent reviews in Victorian retail leases, and combining review mechanisms at the same review date can create compliance issues.

Are rent ratchets legal in Victoria?

For retail leases governed by the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic), a provision that prevents or limits a reduction in rent following a review is void to that extent.

What is a section 28 notice?

A notice a landlord must generally give before the deadline for a tenant to exercise an option to renew a Victorian retail lease. It includes information about the renewal rent and the tenant's rights to an early rent review.

What is an early market rent review?

In circumstances provided by the Retail Leases Act, an early market rent review allows a tenant to have the market rent determined before exercising an option to renew.

What happens if we cannot agree on market rent?

For a Victorian retail lease, the current market rent can be determined by a specialist retail valuer in accordance with the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic).

When should I contact a leasing lawyer about a rent review?

As early as possible. Ideally, get legal advice before a rent review notice is issued, before responding to a landlord's proposed rent, and well before a lease option or renewal deadline.

Related services

What our clients say

5.0 from 22 Google reviews

  • We've used Abbots Legal for a number of retail leasing matters including drafting leases, subleases, assignments, default notices, and urgent injunctions. Nicholas is very knowledgeable, practical and always gives straight advice. They understand the Retail Leases Act and are great to deal with. Would definitely recommend Abbots Legal for retail leasing and landlord matters.

    MeganRetail Leasing

  • I work as an accountant and I have engaged Abbots Legal for a range of business matters, including intellectual property. Professional, responsive and commercially minded every time.

    Joshua O.Commercial Law

  • Our experience with Abbots Legal has been nothing but positive. In particular, Nicholas Kotsimbos went above and beyond for our particular circumstance. Good old fashioned five star customer service!

    Marc C.

  • Highly recommend Abbots Legal. They assisted me with my Will, Power of Attorney, and Medical Decision Maker documents and made the whole process simple and stress free. Professional, efficient, and easy to deal with.

    Nahid K.Wills & Estates

  • Great experience with Abbots Legal. They assisted with a commercial lease matter and made the process smooth and straightforward. Professional, responsive, and easy to deal with. Highly recommend!!

    Sara M.Retail Leasing

  • Abbots Legal provided invaluable support when I purchased my first business. Their guidance was clear, practical, professional and most importantly stress free. Highly recommend

    Ellie T.Commercial Law

  • Excellent advice on establishing our bloodline trust. The team (in particular Nicholas) explained everything clearly and provided very practical guidance for our estate planning.

    Jack V.Wills & Estates

  • Excellent advice on business structuring. The team was knowledgeable, practical, and made the process straightforward from start to finish.

    Aaron H.Business Structuring

  • Nick from Abbots Legal handled our commercial leasing matter quickly and explained everything thoroughly. Bonus that they're around the corner in Richmond.

    Stephanie J.Retail Leasing

  • Had a great experience with Nicholas. His commercial law advice was clear and exactly what I needed.

    Tijen A.Commercial Law

  • Amazing dealing with the team at Abbots Legal. Our estate planning couldn't have been simpler

    Georgette K.Wills & Estates

  • Incredible work by Nick and the team. Had some problems with a tenant and Nick and gotten some great settlement terms. Would highly recommend if you want lawyers that are straight to the point and dont mess about.

    Wiz Z.Litigation & Dispute Resolution

  • Abbots Legal were exceptional when assisting me in the start up of my business. Highly recommend these folk. Good, honest people.

    Jesse F.Business Structuring

  • Nicholas and the team have been there to assist me and my business since day one. Extremely diligent and responsive - would highly recommend

    Jeffrey H.Commercial Law

  • Work in tandem with the team at Abbots Legal daily. Can't fault them and their team. Recommend without hesitation - Ask for Nick

    Gregory S.

  • Nick was very helpful with all proceedings, can't recommend enough 👍

    Jonathan H.