Consider this if…
- You were left out of a will or received less than expected
- You question whether a will is valid
- You are an executor and someone has threatened a claim
- You are concerned about how an executor is handling the estate
- A probate caveat has been lodged or is being considered
How it works
Tell us what has happened
The will, the estate and who is involved.
Today
We identify the claim
Family provision, will validity or an executor dispute.
At the outset
We assess the merits
Eligibility, evidence, time limits and likely costs.
Written estimate first
Negotiation, mediation or court
Settlement is often possible before a final hearing.
As the matter requires
Fee
Quoted in writing before we start
We give you a written estimate before work begins.
Contesting a will in Victoria
"Contesting a will" can describe several different legal claims. The first step is identifying what is actually being disputed.
- Family provision claim. The will may be legally valid, but an eligible person argues that the deceased failed to make adequate provision for them.
- Challenge to the will. The dispute may concern whether the will itself is legally valid and should be admitted to probate.
- Executor or estate administration dispute. The will may be valid, but a dispute arises about the executor's conduct or administration of the estate.
Each type of dispute involves different evidence and legal principles.
Family provision and TFM claims in Victoria
A family provision claim, commonly referred to in Victoria as a Testator's Family Maintenance claim or TFM claim, seeks provision or further provision from a deceased estate.
Claims commonly arise where someone says:
- they were left out of the will
- they received substantially less than expected
- their inheritance is inadequate having regard to their circumstances
- another beneficiary received substantially more
- the deceased failed to make adequate provision for them
Being unhappy with a will does not automatically establish a successful claim. Eligibility and the strength of the claim depend on the circumstances.
Left out of a will
Being completely excluded from a will can be confronting, but it does not automatically mean the will can be overturned.
The relevant question may instead be whether you are eligible to seek further provision from the estate. That assessment can depend on your relationship with the deceased, your financial circumstances, dependency and health, contributions you made to the deceased, the size of the estate and the needs of other beneficiaries.
Advice should be obtained before assuming that being omitted either guarantees or prevents a claim.
Who can make a family provision claim?
Not every relative or person close to the deceased can automatically bring a claim. Depending on the circumstances, eligible applicants can include certain:
- spouses and domestic partners
- former spouses or domestic partners
- children
- stepchildren
- people treated as children of the deceased
- grandchildren
- registered caring partners
- household members
- the spouse or domestic partner of a child who died within a year of the deceased
Some categories, including grandchildren and members of the deceased's household, must show they were wholly or partly dependent on the deceased. For children, matters such as age, study and disability affect how a claim is assessed. Eligibility should therefore be considered at the outset.
Adult children contesting a will
Adult children frequently seek advice about challenging a parent's estate. Being the deceased's child does not mean the Court will simply divide the estate equally.
The matters the Court considers, set out below, apply to adult children as to anyone else, including their financial position, health, contributions to the deceased and the reasons behind the deceased's decisions. Each claim turns on its own facts.
Blended family estate disputes
Blended families can produce particularly difficult estate disputes. Claims may arise between:
- a surviving spouse and adult children
- children from different relationships
- a second spouse and children of an earlier marriage
- stepchildren and biological children
The will may only be part of the picture. Property ownership, superannuation, family trusts and other financial arrangements may also affect the practical outcome.
Time limit to contest a will in Victoria
Estate disputes should be addressed promptly. In Victoria, a family provision claim must generally be filed within six months after the grant of probate or letters of administration. The Court can extend that time, but only if the extension is sought before the estate is finally distributed.
Family provision claims can be heard by the Supreme Court of Victoria, in its Testators Family Maintenance List, or by the County Court.
If you are considering a claim, obtain advice early rather than waiting for the estate to be distributed.
What does the Court consider?
Family provision claims are highly fact-specific. Relevant considerations can include:
- the terms of the will
- the applicant's relationship with the deceased
- financial needs and resources
- health and disability
- dependency
- contributions to the deceased or estate
- the size and nature of the estate
- other beneficiaries
- competing claims
- reasons given by the deceased for the distribution
The Court does not simply decide whether the will was "fair" or divide the estate equally.
Executors defending family provision claims
An executor may receive a family provision claim after obtaining probate. The executor's role is different from that of an ordinary beneficiary.
Depending on the claim, the executor may need to:
- preserve estate assets
- inform relevant beneficiaries
- obtain evidence
- provide information about the estate
- respond to Court proceedings
- participate in mediation
- consider settlement proposals
- avoid distributing the estate prematurely
An executor who receives a demand or Court documents should obtain advice before making further distributions.
Challenging the validity of a will
Some disputes concern whether the will itself should operate. Potential issues can include:
- lack of testamentary capacity
- undue influence
- fraud or forgery
- improper execution
- suspicious circumstances
- whether the deceased knew and approved the contents
- whether a later will exists
- an informal document said to operate as a will
These disputes can determine which document ultimately governs the estate.
Challenging a will for lack of testamentary capacity
Questions about testamentary capacity can arise where the deceased experienced dementia, cognitive decline, serious illness or another condition affecting decision-making.
A diagnosis alone does not automatically make a will invalid. The question concerns the deceased's capacity in relation to the particular will when it was made.
Evidence can include:
- medical records
- the drafting solicitor's file
- witness evidence
- earlier wills
- evidence from family members
- the circumstances surrounding execution
Challenging a will for undue influence
A will may also be challenged where it is alleged that another person improperly influenced the deceased so that the document did not reflect the deceased's genuine intentions. An unusual or unequal will does not itself establish undue influence.
The evidence may need to consider:
- the deceased's vulnerability
- their relationship with the alleged influencer
- isolation from other family members
- significant changes from earlier wills
- how the will was prepared and signed
Probate caveats in Victoria
Where there is a genuine basis for disputing whether a grant of probate should issue, a probate caveat may sometimes be appropriate. A caveat can prevent a grant from being made while the probate issue is addressed.
It should not be used simply because someone considers their inheritance unfair. The legal basis for challenging the grant should be considered first.
Executor and beneficiary estate disputes
Disputes can also arise during the administration of an estate. A beneficiary may allege that an executor:
- is taking too long to administer the estate
- is refusing to provide information
- has failed to account for estate assets
- has a conflict of interest
- has improperly dealt with estate property
- is refusing to distribute without justification
Not every delay amounts to misconduct. The estate's complexity, taxation issues, property sales and potential claims all need to be considered. Our probate and estate administration page explains what an executor has to do.
Estate mediation and settlement
Many estate disputes resolve without a final trial. Mediation can allow the parties to consider:
- the strengths and weaknesses of the claim
- litigation risk
- legal costs
- estate value
- competing beneficiary interests
- commercial certainty
A sensible settlement can preserve substantially more of the estate than prolonged litigation.
Legal costs in estate disputes
The estate does not automatically pay everyone's legal costs. Costs can depend on:
- the type of proceeding
- the merits of the claim
- conduct of the parties
- settlement offers
- the outcome
- orders made by the Court
Costs should therefore form part of the strategy from the beginning.
Estate dispute lawyers in Melbourne
We assist with contesting wills, family provision and TFM claims, will validity disputes, testamentary capacity, undue influence, probate caveats and executor disputes.
Frequently asked questions
Can I contest a will in Victoria?
Potentially. The first question is whether you are seeking further provision from the estate or challenging the validity of the will itself.
Can I contest a will if I was left out?
Potentially. Being left out does not automatically entitle you to part of the estate, but an eligible person may be able to bring a family provision claim.
Can I contest a will because it is unfair?
Not simply because you consider the outcome unfair. The claim needs a recognised legal basis.
What is a family provision claim?
A claim by an eligible person who says the deceased did not make adequate provision for them, asking the Court to order provision from the estate.
What is a Testator's Family Maintenance claim?
TFM, short for Testator's Family Maintenance, is the name commonly used in Victoria for a family provision claim.
Can an adult child contest a parent's will?
Potentially. Eligibility and the merits of the claim depend on the circumstances.
Can a grandchild contest a will?
Potentially in certain circumstances. The relevant eligibility requirements need to be considered.
Can a will be challenged because the deceased had dementia?
Potentially, if there is a genuine issue concerning testamentary capacity when the will was made. The diagnosis itself is not necessarily determinative.
What is a probate caveat?
A probate caveat can prevent a grant from being issued while a genuine probate dispute is addressed.
Does the estate pay everyone's legal costs?
Not automatically. Costs depend on the circumstances and ultimately remain subject to agreement or Court orders.
I am an executor and someone has threatened to contest the will. What should I do?
Obtain legal advice before making final distributions and preserve the relevant estate and will documents.

