Commercial lawyers · Richmond, Melbourne

Two cream armchairs either side of a low table, with a white sofa and a tall window onto city towers beyond

Debt disputes

Not every unpaid debt is an undisputed debt. A person or business may refuse to pay because they dispute the amount claimed, the underlying contract, the goods or services supplied, or whether any money is legally owing. Abbots Legal assists businesses and individuals across Melbourne and Victoria with debt disputes, including disputed invoices, contractual debt claims, set-off and counterclaims, defective or incomplete work and disputes about liability for payment.

Consider this if…

  • A customer or debtor refuses to pay and says the money is not owed
  • You have received a demand for a debt you say is not owing
  • The other side claims a set-off or has a counterclaim
  • You need to know whether a dispute is genuine before you pursue or defend the debt
  • You want to resolve the dispute without going to Court

How it works

  1. Send us the contract and the claim

    The contract and scope of work, the invoices and correspondence, any letter of demand, and evidence of what was supplied or performed.

    As soon as the dispute arises

  2. We assess both positions

    Whether there is a genuine dispute, any breach, set-off or counterclaim, and the strength of each party's position.

    Before you respond, and before any deadline passes

  3. We respond and negotiate

    A response to the demand or to the dispute raised, then negotiation, mediation, a payment arrangement or a settlement, recorded in a deed where appropriate.

    Once you instruct us

  4. Proceedings if needed

    Where the dispute cannot be resolved, we act in the proceedings: a claim for the debt, a defence or a counterclaim.

    If agreement is not reached, or sooner where a deadline applies

Fee

Quoted in writing before we start

Turnaround

Received a demand for a debt you dispute? Tell us the date it arrived and any deadline in it.

What is a debt dispute?

A debt dispute arises where the alleged debtor says that the debt is not payable, is not payable in the amount claimed or is subject to another legal issue.

The dispute may concern:

  • whether a contract exists
  • what the contract requires
  • whether goods or services were supplied
  • whether work was completed properly
  • whether payment has become due
  • the amount claimed
  • whether the contract was breached
  • whether the contract was terminated
  • a set-off or counterclaim, or
  • whether the creditor has complied with its contractual obligations.

Identifying whether there is a genuine dispute is important before deciding how the debt should be pursued or defended.

Common debt disputes

Disputed invoices

A customer may dispute an invoice because goods or services were defective, incomplete, unauthorised or different from what was agreed.

The contract, scope of work, correspondence, invoices and evidence of performance should be reviewed to determine whether the amount is properly payable.

Contractual debt disputes

A debtor may allege that payment is not required because the creditor breached the contract.

These matters may involve claims for damages or other contractual relief in addition to the original debt.

Set-off and counterclaims

A debtor may allege that money claimed should be reduced because the creditor owes money to the debtor.

A debtor may also have a counterclaim arising from the same contract or transaction.

Set-off and counterclaims can materially affect the amount ultimately recoverable and should be assessed before proceedings are commenced.

Responding to a debt claim

If you have received a demand for payment and dispute the debt, ignoring the claim can make the position more difficult.

Depending on the circumstances, it may be necessary to:

  • review the contract
  • assess the amount claimed
  • identify any breach by the other party
  • gather supporting documents
  • identify any set-off or counterclaim
  • respond to the letter of demand
  • negotiate a resolution, or
  • defend legal proceedings.

Early advice can help determine whether the appropriate response is to pay, negotiate, dispute or defend the claim.

Debt disputes and statutory demands

Where a company receives a statutory demand and genuinely disputes the underlying debt, there may be grounds to seek that the demand be set aside, depending on the circumstances.

Strict statutory requirements and time limits apply. A company that receives a statutory demand should obtain legal advice promptly rather than allowing the response period to expire.

Debt disputes and legal proceedings

Where a dispute cannot be resolved, legal proceedings may be necessary. The appropriate forum depends on the nature of the dispute and the parties involved.

The proceeding may involve a claim for the debt, a defence, counterclaim or other contractual relief.

Resolving a debt dispute

Depending on the circumstances, a debt dispute may be resolved through:

  • negotiation
  • mediation
  • a payment arrangement
  • settlement
  • an acknowledgment of debt
  • a deed of settlement, or
  • determination by a Court or tribunal.

The appropriate approach will depend on the strength of each party's position, the amount in dispute and the costs and risks of continuing the matter.

Debt disputes for businesses

Commercial debt disputes can involve substantial contractual and factual issues. The underlying agreement and supporting evidence should be assessed before a recovery or defence strategy is adopted.

Debt dispute lawyers for creditors and debtors

Abbots Legal acts for both creditors seeking payment and businesses or individuals defending disputed debt claims.

We assess the underlying transaction, contractual obligations and available evidence before recommending a practical strategy.

Where appropriate, we assist with negotiation, settlement, mediation and legal proceedings.

Debt dispute lawyers in Melbourne

If you are owed money and the debtor disputes the claim, or you have received a claim for a debt you say is not owing, Abbots Legal can advise on your rights and available options.

Frequently asked questions

What is a genuine debt dispute?

A genuine debt dispute involves a real issue about whether the debt is owing, the amount owing or the creditor's legal entitlement to payment.

What should I do if I receive a letter of demand for a debt I dispute?

The claim should be reviewed promptly. The basis of the dispute should be identified and legal advice obtained before making admissions or simply ignoring the demand.

Can I dispute an unpaid invoice?

Yes. An invoice may be disputed where, for example, the goods or services were defective, incomplete, unauthorised or inconsistent with the agreement.

Can I claim money back from someone who says I owe them money?

Potentially. Depending on the circumstances, a set-off or counterclaim may be available.

Does a debt dispute have to go to Court?

No. Many disputes can be resolved through negotiation, mediation or settlement. Court or tribunal proceedings may be required where the parties cannot reach an agreement.

What our clients say

5.0 from 22 Google reviews

  • We've used Abbots Legal for a number of retail leasing matters including drafting leases, subleases, assignments, default notices, and urgent injunctions. Nicholas is very knowledgeable, practical and always gives straight advice. They understand the Retail Leases Act and are great to deal with. Would definitely recommend Abbots Legal for retail leasing and landlord matters.

    MeganRetail Leasing

  • I work as an accountant and I have engaged Abbots Legal for a range of business matters, including intellectual property. Professional, responsive and commercially minded every time.

    Joshua O.Commercial Law

  • Our experience with Abbots Legal has been nothing but positive. In particular, Nicholas Kotsimbos went above and beyond for our particular circumstance. Good old fashioned five star customer service!

    Marc C.

  • Highly recommend Abbots Legal. They assisted me with my Will, Power of Attorney, and Medical Decision Maker documents and made the whole process simple and stress free. Professional, efficient, and easy to deal with.

    Nahid K.Wills & Estates

  • Great experience with Abbots Legal. They assisted with a commercial lease matter and made the process smooth and straightforward. Professional, responsive, and easy to deal with. Highly recommend!!

    Sara M.Retail Leasing

  • Abbots Legal provided invaluable support when I purchased my first business. Their guidance was clear, practical, professional and most importantly stress free. Highly recommend

    Ellie T.Commercial Law

  • Excellent advice on establishing our bloodline trust. The team (in particular Nicholas) explained everything clearly and provided very practical guidance for our estate planning.

    Jack V.Wills & Estates

  • Excellent advice on business structuring. The team was knowledgeable, practical, and made the process straightforward from start to finish.

    Aaron H.Business Structuring

  • Nick from Abbots Legal handled our commercial leasing matter quickly and explained everything thoroughly. Bonus that they're around the corner in Richmond.

    Stephanie J.Retail Leasing

  • Had a great experience with Nicholas. His commercial law advice was clear and exactly what I needed.

    Tijen A.Commercial Law

  • Amazing dealing with the team at Abbots Legal. Our estate planning couldn't have been simpler

    Georgette K.Wills & Estates

  • Incredible work by Nick and the team. Had some problems with a tenant and Nick and gotten some great settlement terms. Would highly recommend if you want lawyers that are straight to the point and dont mess about.

    Wiz Z.Litigation & Dispute Resolution

  • Abbots Legal were exceptional when assisting me in the start up of my business. Highly recommend these folk. Good, honest people.

    Jesse F.Business Structuring

  • Nicholas and the team have been there to assist me and my business since day one. Extremely diligent and responsive - would highly recommend

    Jeffrey H.Commercial Law

  • Work in tandem with the team at Abbots Legal daily. Can't fault them and their team. Recommend without hesitation - Ask for Nick

    Gregory S.

  • Nick was very helpful with all proceedings, can't recommend enough 👍

    Jonathan H.