Commercial lawyers · Richmond, Melbourne

An arm in a grey T-shirt pulls on a thick cream tug-of-war rope tied with a red cloth marker, with blurred players crouching on a sunlit road behind

Shareholder disputes

Disputes between shareholders can affect the management, profitability and future of a company. They often arise over control, financial decisions, access to information or the conduct of other shareholders and directors. Abbots Legal advises shareholders and private companies throughout Melbourne and Victoria on shareholder disputes.

Heading to court? Litigation and dispute resolution

Consider this if…

  • You have been shut out of decisions or management
  • Shares have been issued that dilute your interest
  • You cannot get access to the company's financial records
  • You and the other shareholder are deadlocked
  • You want to exit and cannot agree on the value of your shares

How it works

  1. Tell us what has happened

    The company, the shareholders and the documents you have.

    Today

  2. We assess your rights

    Under the constitution, any shareholders agreement and the Corporations Act.

    First thing we do

  3. We aim to resolve it

    Negotiation, mediation or a negotiated buyout.

    Where possible

  4. We go to court if needed

    Including urgent orders to protect your position.

    Quoted separately

Fee

Quoted in writing before we start

We quote a fixed fee in writing before any work begins.

Common shareholder disputes

Shareholder disputes can arise in companies of any size, but they are particularly common in privately owned businesses where a small number of individuals control the company.

Common disputes involve:

  • exclusion from company management
  • minority shareholder oppression
  • disagreements about voting rights
  • misuse of company funds
  • alleged dilution of shareholdings
  • disputes concerning dividends
  • denial of access to company information
  • shareholder deadlocks
  • breaches of shareholders agreements
  • shareholder buyouts and valuation disputes
  • allegations of improper conduct by directors

We advise shareholders and companies on their legal position and available remedies, and focus on commercially appropriate solutions.

Minority shareholder oppression

The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) provides remedies in certain circumstances where a company's affairs are conducted in a manner that is oppressive, unfairly prejudicial or unfairly discriminatory.

These protections can be particularly important for minority shareholders who believe they are being unfairly excluded or disadvantaged.

Examples of conduct potentially giving rise to an oppression claim may include:

  • excluding a shareholder from management contrary to established arrangements
  • diverting company funds or opportunities
  • improperly issuing shares to dilute an ownership interest
  • paying excessive remuneration to controlling shareholders
  • withholding information in circumstances amounting to unfair prejudice
  • using company powers to disadvantage particular shareholders

Whether conduct amounts to oppression depends on the circumstances.

We advise on claims under sections 232 and 233 of the Corporations Act and the remedies potentially available.

Remedies for shareholder oppression

The court has broad powers to make orders where the statutory grounds for relief are established.

Depending on the circumstances, orders may include:

  • Share buyouts. Requiring shares to be purchased by another shareholder or the company.
  • Governance orders. Regulating how the company's affairs are conducted.
  • Constitutional changes. Requiring modifications to governance arrangements.
  • Other relief. Orders appropriate to address the oppressive conduct, including winding up in suitable circumstances.

A negotiated buyout may sometimes provide a more practical outcome than prolonged litigation.

Shareholder deadlocks

A deadlock can arise when the shareholders are unable to agree on a significant company decision.

This is especially problematic in companies with equal ownership and voting rights.

Depending on the company's documents and circumstances, available options may include negotiation, mediation, buyout arrangements or court proceedings.

We assist with reviewing the company's constitution and shareholders agreement to determine the appropriate course.

Shareholder buyouts and valuation disputes

A negotiated shareholder exit can be an effective way to resolve a dispute.

However, disagreements often arise over how the departing shareholder's interest should be valued.

Relevant considerations may include the company's assets, earnings, goodwill, minority discounts and the applicable valuation date.

We assist with negotiating shareholder buyouts, obtaining appropriate valuation advice and documenting settlement arrangements.

Shareholder access to company records

Shareholders may seek access to financial statements, company records or other information where they are concerned about the company's affairs.

Access rights depend on the Corporations Act, the company's constitution and any shareholders agreement.

In appropriate circumstances, court orders for inspection of company books may be available.

We advise shareholders and companies on information rights and the legal options available where access is disputed.

Statutory derivative actions

In some circumstances, a shareholder may seek permission to bring proceedings on behalf of the company.

These are commonly referred to as statutory derivative proceedings.

The Corporations Act provides a procedure for eligible applicants to seek court permission where the statutory requirements are satisfied.

These proceedings are distinct from personal shareholder oppression claims.

We advise on the available causes of action and the appropriate procedural pathway.

Urgent shareholder disputes and injunctions

Some corporate disputes require immediate attention.

For example, a shareholder may be concerned about the proposed disposal of company assets, an improper share issue or action that could materially change control of the company.

Depending on the circumstances, urgent injunctive relief may be appropriate to preserve the position while the dispute is determined.

Our litigation and dispute resolution team handles urgent applications and contested proceedings.

Shareholder dispute lawyers in Melbourne

Abbots Legal advises shareholders, directors and private companies throughout Melbourne and Victoria on shareholder disputes and corporate litigation.

We assist with minority shareholder oppression claims, deadlocks, buyouts, valuation disputes, access to company information and applications for court relief.

Frequently asked questions

What is minority shareholder oppression?

Minority shareholder oppression concerns conduct falling within the statutory grounds for relief, including conduct that is oppressive, unfairly prejudicial or unfairly discriminatory in relevant circumstances.

Can a minority shareholder sue a company?

Potentially. The available claims depend on the conduct, the shareholder's rights and the applicable statutory or general law remedies.

Can a shareholder be forced to sell their shares?

Potentially, where a valid contractual mechanism or court order applies.

What happens in a 50/50 shareholder dispute?

The options depend on the company's governing documents and the circumstances. Negotiation, mediation, buyouts and court relief may be available.

Can a shareholder obtain company financial records?

Certain rights may arise under the Corporations Act and the company's documents. Court orders may also be available in appropriate circumstances.

What is a shareholder derivative action?

A statutory derivative action allows an eligible applicant, with court permission, to bring proceedings on behalf of a company in circumstances satisfying the relevant legal requirements.

Related services

What our clients say

5.0 from 22 Google reviews

  • We've used Abbots Legal for a number of retail leasing matters including drafting leases, subleases, assignments, default notices, and urgent injunctions. Nicholas is very knowledgeable, practical and always gives straight advice. They understand the Retail Leases Act and are great to deal with. Would definitely recommend Abbots Legal for retail leasing and landlord matters.

    MeganRetail Leasing

  • I work as an accountant and I have engaged Abbots Legal for a range of business matters, including intellectual property. Professional, responsive and commercially minded every time.

    Joshua O.Commercial Law

  • Our experience with Abbots Legal has been nothing but positive. In particular, Nicholas Kotsimbos went above and beyond for our particular circumstance. Good old fashioned five star customer service!

    Marc C.

  • Highly recommend Abbots Legal. They assisted me with my Will, Power of Attorney, and Medical Decision Maker documents and made the whole process simple and stress free. Professional, efficient, and easy to deal with.

    Nahid K.Wills & Estates

  • Great experience with Abbots Legal. They assisted with a commercial lease matter and made the process smooth and straightforward. Professional, responsive, and easy to deal with. Highly recommend!!

    Sara M.Retail Leasing

  • Abbots Legal provided invaluable support when I purchased my first business. Their guidance was clear, practical, professional and most importantly stress free. Highly recommend

    Ellie T.Commercial Law

  • Excellent advice on establishing our bloodline trust. The team (in particular Nicholas) explained everything clearly and provided very practical guidance for our estate planning.

    Jack V.Wills & Estates

  • Excellent advice on business structuring. The team was knowledgeable, practical, and made the process straightforward from start to finish.

    Aaron H.Business Structuring

  • Nick from Abbots Legal handled our commercial leasing matter quickly and explained everything thoroughly. Bonus that they're around the corner in Richmond.

    Stephanie J.Retail Leasing

  • Had a great experience with Nicholas. His commercial law advice was clear and exactly what I needed.

    Tijen A.Commercial Law

  • Amazing dealing with the team at Abbots Legal. Our estate planning couldn't have been simpler

    Georgette K.Wills & Estates

  • Incredible work by Nick and the team. Had some problems with a tenant and Nick and gotten some great settlement terms. Would highly recommend if you want lawyers that are straight to the point and dont mess about.

    Wiz Z.Litigation & Dispute Resolution

  • Abbots Legal were exceptional when assisting me in the start up of my business. Highly recommend these folk. Good, honest people.

    Jesse F.Business Structuring

  • Nicholas and the team have been there to assist me and my business since day one. Extremely diligent and responsive - would highly recommend

    Jeffrey H.Commercial Law

  • Work in tandem with the team at Abbots Legal daily. Can't fault them and their team. Recommend without hesitation - Ask for Nick

    Gregory S.

  • Nick was very helpful with all proceedings, can't recommend enough 👍

    Jonathan H.